A few small icicles on a sunny winter day are normal. Big, thick icicles hanging along your eavestroughs are a different story. They usually mean snow on the roof is melting from heat escaping through the attic, running down to the cold edge of the roof and refreezing, often with an ice dam forming behind them. Large icicles also add a lot of weight to your eavestroughs, which can bend them or pull them off the fascia, and the water dripping from them refreezes into ice on your walks and steps.
Here is what icicles are telling you, the damage they can do, and how to deal with them safely.
When Icicles Are Normal
Not every icicle is a problem. You can expect a few when:
- Bright sun warms the snow on a south-facing slope during the day, and it refreezes as the sun goes down
- A chinook melts the snow quickly and then temperatures drop again
- Snow on the roof is melting evenly across the whole surface
Small icicles that come and go with the weather, spread fairly evenly along the eaves, are usually just Calgary winter doing its thing.
When Icicles Point to a Problem
Watch for these signs:
- Very large or thick icicles, especially ones that keep growing day after day
- Icicles on a cloudy, cold day, when the sun is not doing the melting
- Icicles concentrated in one area, like above a bathroom, a pot light area or a section with a vaulted ceiling
- A ridge of ice built up along the eaves behind the icicles
- Bare patches on the roof while the rest is still covered in snow
These all suggest heat is escaping into the attic and warming the roof deck from underneath. That melts the snow from below, and the meltwater freezes as soon as it reaches the cold overhang. Our guide on preventing winter ice dams in Alberta explains the attic side of this in more detail.
How Ice Weight Damages Eavestroughs
Eavestroughs are built to carry water, not heavy blocks of ice. When they fill with ice and grow large icicles, several things can go wrong:
- Bent or sagging sections. The trough bows down under the weight, so it no longer drains properly in spring.
- Hangers pulling loose. The fasteners holding the trough to the fascia can pull out, or the fascia itself can be damaged.
- Split seams and corners. Ice expands as it freezes, which can open up seams and joints.
- Cracked or split downspouts. A downspout packed solid with ice can split or come apart at the elbows.
- Troughs torn off completely. In bad cases, a heavy load of ice and sliding snow can rip a section off the house.
Clogged eavestroughs make all of this more likely. Leaves and debris left in the trough hold water and freeze into a solid mass. If damage has already happened, our eavestrough repair service can fix sags, loose hangers and leaking seams once the ice is off.
Refreezing Drips on Walks and Steps
The other big risk sits right below the icicles. During the day, water drips off the icicles and the eaves. At night, it freezes into a hard, slick layer on your:
- Front steps and landing
- Walkways along the side of the house
- Driveway near the garage
- Deck and patio
Downspouts that empty across a walkway add to the problem. This kind of ice can be hard to see and is a real slip hazard, especially for kids, older family members and visitors.
Keeping those spots clear and treated through the winter is important. Our sister company Calgary Snow Pro provides snow removal plus ice control and salting for Calgary homes and businesses, which helps keep walks safe while you work on the root cause.
What Not to Do
- Do not knock icicles down from a ladder. Falling ice is heavy and sharp, and ladders slip easily on ice.
- Do not hit the eavestrough with a broom handle or shovel to break ice loose. That dents and bends the trough.
- Do not stand or let kids play directly under large icicles.
- Do not climb onto a snowy or icy roof to clear the ice behind them. Stay on the ground.
- Do not throw ice melt onto the roof. It can wear on shingles, corrode metal and harm plants below.
If a large icicle is hanging over a doorway or walkway, rope off the area and use another entrance until it can be dealt with safely.
Fixing the Cause
Icicles are a symptom. To get rid of the big ones for good:
- Reduce heat loss into the attic. Air seal gaps around pot lights, the attic hatch and other penetrations, and top up insulation where it is thin.
- Improve attic ventilation. Soffit vents need to stay open so cold air can keep the roof deck cold. Damaged or blocked soffits can be replaced with new soffit and fascia.
- Keep eavestroughs clean before winter. A clean trough drains instead of freezing into a block. Gutter guards help keep debris out, though no guard can stop ice from forming.
- Check slope and downspout placement. Troughs that sag or drain toward the wrong end hold water. Downspouts should carry water away from walks and the foundation.
- Upgrade weak or damaged eavestroughs. Sturdy seamless troughs with good hangers stand up better to Calgary winters.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are icicles a sign my roof is leaking?
Not by themselves. But large icicles often go hand in hand with ice dams, and ice dams can push water under the shingles. If you see icicles and ceiling stains near the outside walls, have it checked.
Should I remove icicles?
Small icicles you can reach from the ground can be carefully knocked off with a long-handled tool, standing well to the side. Large icicles are better left to a professional, and the area below should be kept clear.
Will gutter guards stop icicles?
No. Guards help keep leaves and debris out so the trough can drain, which helps. But icicles come from meltwater refreezing, and that is mostly an attic heat issue.
Can icicles damage my siding or windows?
They can. Falling ice can crack or dent siding and hit windows, and water running behind ice can stain walls. Keeping heavy ice off the eaves protects the whole wall below.
When to Call Us
If your eavestroughs are sagging, pulling loose or split from ice, or you get big icicles every winter, call us. We can repair the eavestroughs and look at the attic and soffit side of the problem. If you are leaning toward a full set of new seamless eavestroughs, we can talk through options and give you a written quote.
Call us at (587) 969-2720.
